New Delhi: According to the India Justice Report 2025, the detained for 3-5 years between 2012 and 2022 doubled in about 10 years for 3-5 years, and people above 5 years have been three times in that period.
The report also found that in 2022, about 22 percent or about four in an undertrial was spent behind bars between 1 and 3 years.
Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Maharashtra simultaneously created 42 percent of all the undertrils in the country by December 2022. Uttar Pradesh had the most responsible for 94,000 undertrils of all undertrils across the country or more than 22 percent.
Show full article
The report is a cooperation and research among various organizations including various organizations including the Center for Social Justice (Adarsh), Common Cause, Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (Chri), South, Tiss-Prayas, Vidhi Center for Legal Policy, and How India Lives, IJR’s data partner. Data for jails has been taken till December 2022.
For more than a decade in the report, from 2012 to 2022, the overall prison occupation increased from 112 percent to 131 percent, and the jail population increased by 49 percent – from 3.8 lakh to 5.7 lakhs.
For the period of pre-testing detention, the report found that on average, undertriater pre-trials were spending more time in custody. Statistics show that about 10 percent of all underratrital in Uttar Pradesh, Meghalaya, West Bengal and Rajasthan spend 3-5 years behind bars.
In Pratriial custody, Purvabhas by former Supreme Court Judge Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul says that a large number of undertrils against the guilty prisoners are a reflection of the problem.
The retired judge wrote, “Justice is not given in Silos but through a network of interdependent institutions. The courts cannot work efficiently, if the police force is understood and untrained. The jails may not be rehabilitated, if legal aid is untreated,”
Budget
Other aspects of the gel system in India were also detected in the report. For example, it saw the approved budgets, and noticed that for jails across the country, the approved budget increased from Rs 3,275 crore to Rs 8,725 crore in a decade from 2012 to 2022.
As a daily expenditure on prisoners, the Andhra Pradesh tops the list-in states of Rs 733 per prisoner-18 large and medium sized states, while Maharashtra spent the lowest-RS 47 per day on its food, medical and educational/vocational training. This is according to data taken for 2022-23.
The report said how this money was also spent. It said that in total, only 0.13 percent of the total expenditure was used for commercial and educational facilities and only 0.27 percent was spent on welfare activities.
The report states, “While on paper, on paper, for rehabilitation for rehabilitation, fiscal rehabilitation seems to be a distant dream,” the report states.
Bonds and policies
Supreme Court lawyer Nipun Saxena says the figures are not surprising.
He referred to Section 436A of the previous Code of Criminal Process Code (CRPC), specifing the maximum duration for which an undertaking prisoner could be detained. It states that if a person spent more than half of the maximum period of imprisonment specified for the crime under which he has been accused, the person will be released by the court on his personal bond or without certainty.
Section 479 of the new Indian Municipal Emperor Code (BNSS) retains this provision, but one third of the imprisonment period determines the maximum period for which the culprit can be detained for the first time, and retains a half period for others.
Saxena also stated that the Supreme Court had returned in the 1970s, stressing the importance of bail grant, stating that bail could be given on personal bond without any certainty if the circumstances allow it.
“I don’t know why this decision is not being followed. I think it should be taught in national judicial academies,” he said.
Another contribution factor, according to Saxena, is delayed in verification of certainty for the sheer number of the undertrier, that is, the person who guarantees the judge that the accused will appear before the court and follow all the bail conditions.
He said, “Orders can be passed several times, but due to bail verification, who walk for age, Bells is rejected,” he said.
Another important indicator is the fact that the gel is a state subject under the Constitution. He said, “There is no uniform policy in the states for undertriater management.”
(Edited by Tony Rai)
Also read: 10,000+ Indian citizens registered in foreign jails, 47 executed in 2020-24-Gowt told Rajya Sabha